Skip to content

New conversations, in your inbox.

Subscribe Free
Studying Law
Episode 207

Elevating the Client Experience, Making Risk Visible, and Embracing Stretch Opportunities with Victoria Crewe-Nelson

with Victoria Crewe-NelsonCanada00:30:04Nov 13, 2026
Elevating the Client Experience, Making Risk Visible, and Embracing Stretch Opportunities with Victoria Crewe-Nelson
0:0030:04

Transcript

Open full

This transcript was generated by AI and may contain minor inaccuracies.

Welcome to Studying Law Around the World. I'm Claudio Claus. In each episode, I talk with lawyers, law students, and professors from different parts of the world to talk about legal education, careers, and what the profession looks like in real life. We talk about the hard parts, the surprises, and the decisions that shaped their paths. Whether you're planning to study abroad, thinking about working in another legal system, or just curious about how law works around the world, this podcast is for you. This evening, I have the privilege of being joined by Victoria Creel Nelson. She has an incredible story. She is a Vice President, Underwriting and Customer Service and Secretary at LawPro Canada. She has joined LawPro in 2022 as Assistant VP in Underwriting, and before joining LawPro, she had gained experience in practice areas including corporate and commercial litigations, estates and trusts, real estate, and admiralty law. I'm very excited to have you here in the podcast today. Thank you so much for making the time to join me this evening, Victoria. Thank you, Claudio. Before we go into any of the questions, I just want to do a really quick disclaimer. Anything we talk about today, this is in my personal capacity. So the views I express are my own. They don't necessarily reflect the views or positions of LawPro. And of course, no matter what I say, nothing we discuss should be taken as legal advice. There, I said it. I appreciate that. Thank you so much. I'd love for you to introduce yourself a little bit to us. Tell us a little bit about your background and your path from private practice into executive leadership. Okay. Well, I had a somewhat eclectic route into law and probably an even more eclectic career once I got here. At various times, I did not intend to be a lawyer, and that was pretty much through my entire legal studies. And then I wanted to be a variety of different types of lawyers, and then I ended up working in a career where it's a non-lawyer role, but you have to be a lawyer to do it. So I did study law in Canada and the UK, specifically Scotland. So shout out to all of my hybrid legal colleagues out there. And like you said, I articled in admiralty and then I had a really broad general practice once I was actually in practice. And there was very little that came in the door that I wasn't willing to take a shot at, but at heart I was always Like an old-fashioned solicitor. And I loved being that person where somebody would come in with their kids and they would tell their kids, this is the woman who's gonna help you when it's your turn to buy a house or to set up a business or to do up your wills and estates. And I loved that trust that they put in me. It was just an overwhelming amount of trust that I always felt from all of these clients. And I just wanted to do my best for them. I wanted to come up with solutions to take the weight off of their shoulders. So even though we talked about the fact that I'm no longer a practicing lawyer, it wasn't because I hated being a lawyer. I liked being a lawyer. I loved clients, even my many very full of character clients. But what changed for me over time was my understanding of what being a lawyer could mean. I always had a lot of respect for the Law Society and for LawPro, and I thought eventually I might want to join one of those organizations. And earlier in my career, I had an opportunity to go over, but it wasn't the right role for me, and I knew that pretty much right away. But once I heard about this underwriting opportunity, I was hooked from day one. I joined LawPro, actually it was back in 2000, and suddenly I was seeing the legal profession from an entirely different perspective than when I was practicing. Instead of helping one client, and this is what you're going to hear from everybody who ends up going in-house in one degree or another, you're really taking care of an organization. But even more in my role, I was looking at issues that are affecting all lawyers in Ontario, from professional liability to claims trends, risk management, how insurance can support them, help protect their clients. And it just gave me this whole new way of looking at how I could apply my legal skills. And then over time, my responsibilities broadened. So as much as I started out as an AVP of underwriting, now I'm a VP and board secretary. And my work day to day, it touches on insurance and reinsurance. And I won't bore your listeners talking about reinsurance, which I definitely could do. But I'm looking at professional liability. I'm looking at customer experience. governance, technology, organizational change, and increasingly things that touch on everybody's practices like cyber risk and artificial intelligence. I really appreciate you sharing that. As you, as, as our listeners are used to hearing here in the podcast and listening, this is a show where I try to speak a lot to early career professionals, lawyers who are still starting their careers, or even law students who are trying to have a better idea of what practice can look like. So it's, it's so interesting that being a lawyer does not require a traditional legal role. I think that, that your story talks a lot about that and your current role sits at a very, very interesting intersection. You just mentioned a few of the things that you work on and you see, and the risk management aspect, governance, the customer service. It's amazing. I'm curious too, since you mentioned thinking about your 25-year-old self, how has working on the risk side of the profession changed the way you think about what makes a good lawyer? That's, that's a good question. So insurance, it, it makes you think about things that have already gone wrong a lot of the time. And so you're always taking this backwards look. And what it teaches you is good lawyers make bad decisions or bad things happen to good lawyers. You would think that coming here, we'd be going through these claim files and I'd see that they're confined to bad lawyers, but very good, intelligent, conscientious lawyers, they can make mistakes or they can have bad things imposed on them. My very favorite lawyers who I would refer anybody to in a heartbeat, I'm sure they have claims with LawPro. And so it isn't, when I was in law school, if you had asked me what kind of claims get reported to LawPro, I would have said it's technical knowledge. It's people giving advice on criminal law who shouldn't be giving advice on criminal law or not understanding the limitation period. All the things that we study for in the bar exams, those are the things that I thought would be the reasons that you have to report things to LawPro. But no, more often it's communication. It's having assumptions that you're not double checking. It's missed deadlines. It's unclear instructions. Inadequate supervision, trusting the wrong people or trusting the wrong process. And it's really changed how I think about professional excellence because table stakes, we're assuming that people know the law. That's just fundamental. But being a really good lawyer requires more than just knowing the answers to things. Obviously it requires judgment. Requires judgment about knowing when to say something and when not to say something, um, how to best direct and guide a client. But it also requires knowing when something doesn't look or smell right. It requires knowing when you don't know the answer and how to communicate that to your client in a way so that they still have trust and faith in you. It requires communicating in a way that makes your client actually understand your advice. More and more, it's about overseeing the work of those who support you or other things that support you, and definitely providing good guidance and support to help the people who are supporting you excel in their jobs. And always, it's thinking about risk. I do know sometimes people will ask me when we're discussing a new idea, why do I always go to everything that could go wrong? I never start with, that's a fantastic idea. I could see how it's going to make all of this money and all these other things. But the lawyer and the underwriter in me always has to start with what are the risks? And it's not me saying why we shouldn't do something, but it's me saying, assume we're going to go forward with this. What could go wrong? What do we need to put in place so that we can mitigate it so we can achieve some kind of success? And I think that's an important distinction. Lawyers get a bad rap for being too cautious or not having a growth mindset. And I think we really do have a growth mindset. But our job is to make risk visible to our clients and to our other stakeholders so that they can always make informed decisions about which risks they're prepared to take. And I don't know if I appreciated before just how important that skill set is and communicating it to our clients. Amazing. I see here that you've posted a few interesting things here, texts and articles on LinkedIn. I wanted to ask you, you spoke a few times or wrote a few times about professional liability and mistakes that can create great consequences for lawyers. Thinking about these young lawyers who are coming into the career now, are there a few mistakes or risks that maybe young lawyers tend to underestimate early in their careers a little more than the more senior lawyers? Maybe even when they are technically strong, since you mentioned the technical aspect of it. Yeah, we definitely see differences in the types of mistakes that younger lawyers versus more experienced lawyers are necessarily going to make. And sometimes it is that technical knowledge, like a more senior lawyer would just know off the drop of a pin exactly what case to cite or that kind of thing. But there's some things that really are universal across everybody. And the first one is communication. And I don't care what area of practice you're in, but I think people would be surprised how often 2 people leave a meeting and there's no consensus at item. They did not come out of it with the same understanding of what was said or what the next steps were. And especially with the way things are now, it doesn't matter if you're giving advice to somebody who's buying real estate, going through personal injury, if you're an in-house lawyer and you're working on a big tech transition. If you're doing a performance improvement plan for one of your staff who, you know, need a little bit of help to improve, but having really clear instructions written down afterwards is so important. Then maybe this one does come up a little bit more for younger lawyers. I'm going to call it silent uncertainty. And this is where it could be a little bit awkward when you don't know the answer to something. And it can be awkward in a couple of different ways. So sometimes it's that feeling that people are expecting you to have an answer. Your clients are expecting you to have an answer, especially if they've got your cell phone number and they're texting you and they expect an answer immediately. And it's important to know that you're not expected to know everything. And competence doesn't mean knowing every answer. It includes knowing when to ask a question or when to stop. That conversation that you're having with the client to let them know, I'm gonna have to take this away and get more information afterwards. And sometimes it can take a little bit of time to develop this skill. When you give an answer, when you haven't had a chance to double-check it, or if you're feeling a little uncomfortable about the advice that you're giving, 'cause you're not entirely certain about it, Mm-hmm. You're one, you're setting unrealistic expectations with your clients. They're always going to expect you to come up with really fast, easy answers. And they don't understand that these things need to be researched and looked into and thought put into them. And they're also going to expect you to drop what you're doing, no matter what you're in the middle of in the future for them. And those aren't really things that you want to teach your clients. What you want to teach them is that. They pose a question, you'll let them know when you're going to get back to them, and you're going to give them the best answer available to you. And sometimes that just means stopping and knowing when to ask for help or to do a bit more research. And then increasingly, I can say this for LawPro, increasingly we are seeing a lot of frauds being aimed at lawyers. And so trust without verification is a big issue, especially for Younger lawyers where again, it can be awkward to stop and do what you need to do to make sure that everything is on the up and up. When you're dealing with fraudsters, they always give this sense of urgency. I need to get the money out immediately or this other disaster is going to fall. And especially if you're a younger lawyer, it can be very easy for them to bully you into making those fast decisions, those fast actions. And it can be difficult to have that conversation with a client of, no, I can't do it right now. I have to stop and verify the funds. Or you've gotten in those new instructions for sending the funds to a different place than what the client originally told you because a fraudster has taken over a similar email and sent it to you. It's not your client at all. But when you have to stop and actually phone up and verify it, and you're thinking, I'm being 10 kinds of paranoid, But you have to be 10 kinds of paranoid and you might be worried about insulting or getting on the wrong side of your client. Trust me, they will always be happier that you prevented a fraud than any small snub by phoning up and interrupting them during the day. So I'd say healthy skepticism is incredibly important. There's a few other things that are quite interesting that you've shared, but you also have been writing about AI, cyber risk, social engineering. lawyers' responsibilities for AI-generated work. So also in this, in this topic of what can we do better as young lawyers, early career professionals, what do you think lawyers need to understand about using AI responsibly? And where do you see the biggest risks emerging at this moment? I am glad that you haven't been fooled by my LinkedIn warnings, because I think if somebody just watched what I actually write on LinkedIn, they would think that I am all about trying to scare people away from AI. When secretly I'm actually very enthusiastic about AI. I think it has enormous potential to make lawyers more productive, help us analyze information and risks, and make legal services more accessible to the public, which is really important. So before I go into anything else, this isn't about why lawyers shouldn't use AI, but as I said earlier, I am an underwriter and a lawyer, so I'm going to point out all the risks associated with this. If an AI tool produces something that looks like legal work, I think people sometimes forget that responsibility for that work hasn't somehow transferred from the lawyer over to whoever is running that AI generator. The lawyer is the one who's responsible in the same way that you'd be responsible for a clerk or a junior associate or anyone else who's doing work and you're signing off on it and it's going out under your name. And so I think about the way to think about responsibility when it comes to AI. If I was still a student, I'd come up with a really good acronym for this, but it's about confidentiality, competence, verification, and accountability. So you should be asking yourself before you do anything, like first one I ask myself is about confidentiality. What information am I putting into the AI tool? And am I even entitled to put that information in? And you should always have a related question in your mind about what will that information be used for? Where is it going to be housed? All of those risks. So confidentiality, number one, we're lawyers, we should be worried about this. And then it's competence. These tools make everything look really easy, but do I understand enough about this area of law, about the tool that I'm using, about its limitations, that what I put in here, am I going to get the result I need? Are my skills appropriate enough to get the objective I want? And so part of that is, do I understand the area of law enough that if the AI tool spits out complete garbage, am I going to be able to identify that? Or am I going to be somehow fooled by this generator? If I keep questioning it, do you want to give me other sources and everything, and it keeps giving me gobbledygook, do I have the skills to recognize that? Even with What I put into the search when I'm asking it for assistance with something. Am I able to frame the question appropriately, or do I not even have the skills for that? So you have to build up your confidence in this area. The third is going to be about verification. Have I independently verified the output? That sounds authoritative enough. And the fourth one is going back to accountability. Am I prepared to take professional responsibility for the work I'm putting forward? If you're just using your licensed Copilot to make your emails sound more structured, which that is definitely something I do, that's one thing. But if you're just going to hand your entire practice over to AI and think that it's going to go well, you're being incredibly naive. And the mistakes that this will cause for you on every level. From a regulatory perspective, from a client management perspective, from court and costs and everything else, you cannot do this. AI is going to assist you, but it cannot assume your professional responsibility. I understand that you've worked on customer experience, digital transformation, organizational change. So those are all very interesting topics that I don't think many lawyers have the chance to work with or be trained on that service design or the client experience. What can the legal profession learn from other industries about making services more accessible, easier to navigate? I love this question. So when I was starting out, I always heard law is a profession, not a business. Did you hear this as well? Absolutely. Absolutely. And some people will say it's a vocation as well, right? That's exactly it. And it was almost like it was repellent to us to think about the business angle of being a lawyer. And so, no, I don't agree with the statement anymore. I'm— it is absolutely true that we are part of a highly principled profession, a highly principled regulated profession, and that we should all be held to a really high standard. But it's also a highly competitive marketplace. Where we all need to think about what can we do to make ourselves stand out from the crowd. And for especially your listeners that are just starting out, they have to think about how they're going to develop their careers so that they will be fulfilling, that they will support their lifestyle, how they can provide service to others. And of course, because I'm a law pro, how they can meet their professional obligations. So looking at my own background and the different careers I worked in, I'm fortunate that I spent a lot of time in customer service centered fields, and customer service is paramount to being a lawyer in your interactions with your clients. And I don't think that lawyers necessarily understand that clients do not separate the quality of the professional advice or product from the experience that they're receiving. You could provide technically excellent advice, but the client is also experiencing that email that wasn't answered, the bill they didn't understand, the life event that they told you about, but you very obviously did not remember in the next meeting that you had with them, the forms that are confusing, and even any kind of industry, things like your website, if it's hard to navigate that or— You're using terminology that they can't understand. These are all really detracting from the client experience and it's telling against you. And so yeah, customer service and having that kind of project management transformation mindset. Amazing. Thank you for sharing those. I think those are always things that we should constantly be mindful of and be studying and looking at. Once those are in place, it just makes such a difference to get into a workplace that everyone knows what the policies are. Everybody feels a lot more secure and safe to do their work, and they know what the policies are regarding YXE. They know how to navigate those. I loved that you started answering the last question talking about how there is a business and that we need to be aware of that, right? And to be able to support our livelihoods and all of that, we need to differentiate ourselves in this market. So I'm curious about your personal view. What do you think that lawyers should be doing for those especially who are trying to figure out what they want to become known for professionally? Do you have a few ideas on that? Yes. So I know a lot of times I talk about, um, I fell into a niche. I became an expert in an area. And once you're an expert in an area, people come to you, you get more business this way. Once you've got a reputation and an area. So for example, even when I was in admiralty, if there are 4 admiralty firms in the city, well, obviously they're gonna get business cuz there are only 4 of them, but they're so well known, everyone's gonna go to them. But what I find more often than not is that people don't fall into expertise. What they do is they develop their own niche and it's important how you do that. I liked being an expert on things. I was also a generalist for a long time, so I think it's great being a Generalist. But for me, yes, I like to be a subject matter expert and it does, it does steer a lot of business towards you. Over the course of my career, I've become increasingly knowledgeable in certain areas. I'm an underwriter and I specialize in lawyers' professional liability. It is somewhat of a niche area for me to be in, but also as my career has progressed, as I've become a more senior executive, I'd say if somebody was looking at the beginning of their career on how to build that right career for you, it's gonna start with curiosity, paying attention to the things that you find yourself reading about, even when you don't have to do it cuz nobody's assigned it to you. Paying attention to the questions that colleagues keep asking you. Maybe they figured out that you've got an aptitude in a certain area and this is something worth exploring a little bit more. And just keep learning, just constantly keep learning. So as you help other people understand something, people will know that you're the expert in this area. People are gonna start coming to you, and then they're gonna see you're an OBA section executive and you write on LinkedIn about this kind of stuff all the time. Can they pick your brain on something? Can you co-counsel with them? Can they send referrals over to you? You're building your own niche at this point just by letting people know this is something you're really interested in and you want to share that knowledge with others. So if you think about it, it's like curiosity is going to lead you to competence. Competence is going to lead you to contribute to the legal community. And that's when you build up your reputation. And don't wait until you know everything before you start to contribute, because you're never going to know everything in the field. I don't know everything about lawyers' professional liability, and I've devoted a heck of a lot of time to studying this. You're never going to be the subject matter expert that knows everything. You're going to become that expert that is continually learning, and you're willing to share what you've learned, and you're willing to stop and ask questions and learn more along the way. That's beautiful. Thank you so much, Victoria. It's been incredible to, to learn from you during this podcast. I really appreciate your insights. And coming towards the end of our conversation today, I wanted to ask you What advice would you give to law students who may eventually want to move beyond traditional practice into governance, legal operations, technology, or any other legal adjacent role? Did you feel like being the best lawyer you could be while being a full-time practicing lawyer was really the step to be done? That curiosity that you've mentioned throughout the podcast today, what are some of your thoughts on that? Yeah, no, it was definitely more about being curious. But it was having that varied and interesting background. And it was learning, I would say also that what helps you move out of law into another field, it's learning a little bit about all the different aspects of whatever business it is that you're going into. You might start out thinking, this is my narrow role that I'm going to have within the organization. And if that's all you ever want to do for your entire career, then I guess that's okay. But if you don't learn about what's going on in the other departments and what motivates the other aspects of their operations, support teams, their boards, you're never going to get the full flavor of all of the opportunities that are with that organization. And definitely you should volunteer for problems, not just positions. Some of the most valuable opportunities I've had in my career haven't arrived perfectly packaged as a promotion. They've arrived as complicated problems that needed somebody to figure them out. And because I stepped in, I saw that gap, suddenly people are relying on me. And so sometimes it's taking something that looks messy. That nobody else particularly wants and owning it. And that could be an incredibly useful way of moving forward and taking that kind of, that stretch assignment. So you're trying something totally outside of your comfort zone and discovering where you might have an aptitude or skill outside of traditional practice of law. And if you can take ambiguity, if you can understand a problem that maybe isn't obvious to other people when they first look at it. And you can figure out how to bring the right people together or come up with a novel solution, then even though you're not even in a position of leadership yet, you are naturally a leader. You are showing leadership tendencies. And for me and countless other people, when we're looking at moving people up into leadership roles, we're looking for these kinds of attributes, people who already became leaders, even though we never gave them a title for it, because they naturally knew when to step in and support other people. And I think I've said this one a couple of times. Don't wait until you feel you're completely ready for an opportunity to go for it. And I know that as lawyers and underwriters, we are, we can be really cautious about things. And so sometimes it can be really uncomfortable to step outside our comfort zone and take on something that we don't think that we're ready for yet. But you do it and you do it and you adapt. And you stumble and you learn about the role or the problem that you took on, and you learn about yourself and your own grit, and you learn that your career doesn't have to be a straight line. And some of the things that I've enjoyed most about my career were things that I never knew about at the start of my career were ever going to be opportunities or possibilities for me. So I guess my closing advice to people would be your law degree, it gives you options. It doesn't impose an obligation on you to be a lawyer or to practice in a particular way. You get to decide how your own career in law is going to be defined. And it doesn't necessarily mean in private practice. It means whatever you decide it's going to be. Amazing. Thank you so much for making the time to come on the show and share a little bit about your career, some incredible pieces of advice. For those of you listening, thank you so much for making the time to come and listen to the podcast today. I hope you took some notes, and if you haven't, feel free to, to go over and listen to it again. So many great pieces for us to have in our, in our life going forward. I really appreciate it Thank you.

Welcome to Studying Law Around the World. I'm Claudio Claus. In each episode, I talk with lawyers, law students, and professors from different parts of the world to talk about legal education, careers, and what the profession looks like in real life. We talk about the hard parts, the surprises, and the decisions that shaped their paths. Whether you're planning to study abroad, thinking about working in another legal system, or just curious about how law works around the world, this podcast is for you. This evening, I have the privilege of being joined by Victoria Creel Nelson. She has an incredible story. She is a Vice President, Underwriting and Customer Service and Secretary at LawPro Canada. She has joined LawPro in 2022 as Assistant VP in Underwriting, and before joining LawPro, she had gained experience in practice areas including corporate and commercial litigations, estates and trusts, real estate, and admiralty law. I'm very excited to have you here in the podcast today. Thank you so much for making the time to join me this evening, Victoria. Thank you, Claudio. Before we go into any of the questions, I just want to do a really quick disclaimer. Anything we talk about today, this is in my personal capacity. So the views I express are my own. They don't necessarily reflect the views or positions of LawPro. And of course, no matter what I say, nothing we discuss should be taken as legal advice. There, I said it. I appreciate that. Thank you so much. I'd love for you to introduce yourself a little bit to us. Tell us a little bit about your background and your path from private practice into executive leadership. Okay. Well, I had a somewhat eclectic route into law and probably an even more eclectic career once I got here. At various times, I did not intend to be a lawyer, and that was pretty much through my entire legal studies. And then I wanted to be a variety of different types of lawyers, and then I ended up working in a career where it's a non-lawyer role, but you have to be a lawyer to do it. So I did study law in Canada and the UK, specifically Scotland. So shout out to all of my hybrid legal colleagues out there. And like you said, I articled in admiralty and then I had a really broad general practice once I was actually in practice. And there was very little that came in the door that I wasn't willing to take a shot at, but at heart I was always Like an old-fashioned solicitor. And I loved being that person where somebody would come in with their kids and they would tell their kids, this is the woman who's gonna help you when it's your turn to buy a house or to set up a business or to do up your wills and estates. And I loved that trust that they put in me. It was just an overwhelming amount of trust that I always felt from all of these clients. And I just wanted to do my best for them. I wanted to come up with solutions to take the weight off of their shoulders. So even though we talked about the fact that I'm no longer a practicing lawyer, it wasn't because I hated being a lawyer. I liked being a lawyer. I loved clients, even my many very full of character clients. But what changed for me over time was my understanding of what being a lawyer could mean. I always had a lot of respect for the Law Society and for LawPro, and I thought eventually I might want to join one of those organizations. And earlier in my career, I had an opportunity to go over, but it wasn't the right role for me, and I knew that pretty much right away. But once I heard about this underwriting opportunity, I was hooked from day one. I joined LawPro, actually it was back in 2000, and suddenly I was seeing the legal profession from an entirely different perspective than when I was practicing. Instead of helping one client, and this is what you're going to hear from everybody who ends up going in-house in one degree or another, you're really taking care of an organization. But even more in my role, I was looking at issues that are affecting all lawyers in Ontario, from professional liability to claims trends, risk management, how insurance can support them, help protect their clients. And it just gave me this whole new way of looking at how I could apply my legal skills. And then over time, my responsibilities broadened. So as much as I started out as an AVP of underwriting, now I'm a VP and board secretary. And my work day to day, it touches on insurance and reinsurance. And I won't bore your listeners talking about reinsurance, which I definitely could do. But I'm looking at professional liability. I'm looking at customer experience. governance, technology, organizational change, and increasingly things that touch on everybody's practices like cyber risk and artificial intelligence. I really appreciate you sharing that. As you, as, as our listeners are used to hearing here in the podcast and listening, this is a show where I try to speak a lot to early career professionals, lawyers who are still starting their careers, or even law students who are trying to have a better idea of what practice can look like. So it's, it's so interesting that being a lawyer does not require a traditional legal role. I think that, that your story talks a lot about that and your current role sits at a very, very interesting intersection. You just mentioned a few of the things that you work on and you see, and the risk management aspect, governance, the customer service. It's amazing. I'm curious too, since you mentioned thinking about your 25-year-old self, how has working on the risk side of the profession changed the way you think about what makes a good lawyer? That's, that's a good question. So insurance, it, it makes you think about things that have already gone wrong a lot of the time. And so you're always taking this backwards look. And what it teaches you is good lawyers make bad decisions or bad things happen to good lawyers. You would think that coming here, we'd be going through these claim files and I'd see that they're confined to bad lawyers, but very good, intelligent, conscientious lawyers, they can make mistakes or they can have bad things imposed on them. My very favorite lawyers who I would refer anybody to in a heartbeat, I'm sure they have claims with LawPro. And so it isn't, when I was in law school, if you had asked me what kind of claims get reported to LawPro, I would have said it's technical knowledge. It's people giving advice on criminal law who shouldn't be giving advice on criminal law or not understanding the limitation period. All the things that we study for in the bar exams, those are the things that I thought would be the reasons that you have to report things to LawPro. But no, more often it's communication. It's having assumptions that you're not double checking. It's missed deadlines. It's unclear instructions. Inadequate supervision, trusting the wrong people or trusting the wrong process. And it's really changed how I think about professional excellence because table stakes, we're assuming that people know the law. That's just fundamental. But being a really good lawyer requires more than just knowing the answers to things. Obviously it requires judgment. Requires judgment about knowing when to say something and when not to say something, um, how to best direct and guide a client. But it also requires knowing when something doesn't look or smell right. It requires knowing when you don't know the answer and how to communicate that to your client in a way so that they still have trust and faith in you. It requires communicating in a way that makes your client actually understand your advice. More and more, it's about overseeing the work of those who support you or other things that support you, and definitely providing good guidance and support to help the people who are supporting you excel in their jobs. And always, it's thinking about risk. I do know sometimes people will ask me when we're discussing a new idea, why do I always go to everything that could go wrong? I never start with, that's a fantastic idea. I could see how it's going to make all of this money and all these other things. But the lawyer and the underwriter in me always has to start with what are the risks? And it's not me saying why we shouldn't do something, but it's me saying, assume we're going to go forward with this. What could go wrong? What do we need to put in place so that we can mitigate it so we can achieve some kind of success? And I think that's an important distinction. Lawyers get a bad rap for being too cautious or not having a growth mindset. And I think we really do have a growth mindset. But our job is to make risk visible to our clients and to our other stakeholders so that they can always make informed decisions about which risks they're prepared to take. And I don't know if I appreciated before just how important that skill set is and communicating it to our clients. Amazing. I see here that you've posted a few interesting things here, texts and articles on LinkedIn. I wanted to ask you, you spoke a few times or wrote a few times about professional liability and mistakes that can create great consequences for lawyers. Thinking about these young lawyers who are coming into the career now, are there a few mistakes or risks that maybe young lawyers tend to underestimate early in their careers a little more than the more senior lawyers? Maybe even when they are technically strong, since you mentioned the technical aspect of it. Yeah, we definitely see differences in the types of mistakes that younger lawyers versus more experienced lawyers are necessarily going to make. And sometimes it is that technical knowledge, like a more senior lawyer would just know off the drop of a pin exactly what case to cite or that kind of thing. But there's some things that really are universal across everybody. And the first one is communication. And I don't care what area of practice you're in, but I think people would be surprised how often 2 people leave a meeting and there's no consensus at item. They did not come out of it with the same understanding of what was said or what the next steps were. And especially with the way things are now, it doesn't matter if you're giving advice to somebody who's buying real estate, going through personal injury, if you're an in-house lawyer and you're working on a big tech transition. If you're doing a performance improvement plan for one of your staff who, you know, need a little bit of help to improve, but having really clear instructions written down afterwards is so important. Then maybe this one does come up a little bit more for younger lawyers. I'm going to call it silent uncertainty. And this is where it could be a little bit awkward when you don't know the answer to something. And it can be awkward in a couple of different ways. So sometimes it's that feeling that people are expecting you to have an answer. Your clients are expecting you to have an answer, especially if they've got your cell phone number and they're texting you and they expect an answer immediately. And it's important to know that you're not expected to know everything. And competence doesn't mean knowing every answer. It includes knowing when to ask a question or when to stop. That conversation that you're having with the client to let them know, I'm gonna have to take this away and get more information afterwards. And sometimes it can take a little bit of time to develop this skill. When you give an answer, when you haven't had a chance to double-check it, or if you're feeling a little uncomfortable about the advice that you're giving, 'cause you're not entirely certain about it, Mm-hmm. You're one, you're setting unrealistic expectations with your clients. They're always going to expect you to come up with really fast, easy answers. And they don't understand that these things need to be researched and looked into and thought put into them. And they're also going to expect you to drop what you're doing, no matter what you're in the middle of in the future for them. And those aren't really things that you want to teach your clients. What you want to teach them is that. They pose a question, you'll let them know when you're going to get back to them, and you're going to give them the best answer available to you. And sometimes that just means stopping and knowing when to ask for help or to do a bit more research. And then increasingly, I can say this for LawPro, increasingly we are seeing a lot of frauds being aimed at lawyers. And so trust without verification is a big issue, especially for Younger lawyers where again, it can be awkward to stop and do what you need to do to make sure that everything is on the up and up. When you're dealing with fraudsters, they always give this sense of urgency. I need to get the money out immediately or this other disaster is going to fall. And especially if you're a younger lawyer, it can be very easy for them to bully you into making those fast decisions, those fast actions. And it can be difficult to have that conversation with a client of, no, I can't do it right now. I have to stop and verify the funds. Or you've gotten in those new instructions for sending the funds to a different place than what the client originally told you because a fraudster has taken over a similar email and sent it to you. It's not your client at all. But when you have to stop and actually phone up and verify it, and you're thinking, I'm being 10 kinds of paranoid, But you have to be 10 kinds of paranoid and you might be worried about insulting or getting on the wrong side of your client. Trust me, they will always be happier that you prevented a fraud than any small snub by phoning up and interrupting them during the day. So I'd say healthy skepticism is incredibly important. There's a few other things that are quite interesting that you've shared, but you also have been writing about AI, cyber risk, social engineering. lawyers' responsibilities for AI-generated work. So also in this, in this topic of what can we do better as young lawyers, early career professionals, what do you think lawyers need to understand about using AI responsibly? And where do you see the biggest risks emerging at this moment? I am glad that you haven't been fooled by my LinkedIn warnings, because I think if somebody just watched what I actually write on LinkedIn, they would think that I am all about trying to scare people away from AI. When secretly I'm actually very enthusiastic about AI. I think it has enormous potential to make lawyers more productive, help us analyze information and risks, and make legal services more accessible to the public, which is really important. So before I go into anything else, this isn't about why lawyers shouldn't use AI, but as I said earlier, I am an underwriter and a lawyer, so I'm going to point out all the risks associated with this. If an AI tool produces something that looks like legal work, I think people sometimes forget that responsibility for that work hasn't somehow transferred from the lawyer over to whoever is running that AI generator. The lawyer is the one who's responsible in the same way that you'd be responsible for a clerk or a junior associate or anyone else who's doing work and you're signing off on it and it's going out under your name. And so I think about the way to think about responsibility when it comes to AI. If I was still a student, I'd come up with a really good acronym for this, but it's about confidentiality, competence, verification, and accountability. So you should be asking yourself before you do anything, like first one I ask myself is about confidentiality. What information am I putting into the AI tool? And am I even entitled to put that information in? And you should always have a related question in your mind about what will that information be used for? Where is it going to be housed? All of those risks. So confidentiality, number one, we're lawyers, we should be worried about this. And then it's competence. These tools make everything look really easy, but do I understand enough about this area of law, about the tool that I'm using, about its limitations, that what I put in here, am I going to get the result I need? Are my skills appropriate enough to get the objective I want? And so part of that is, do I understand the area of law enough that if the AI tool spits out complete garbage, am I going to be able to identify that? Or am I going to be somehow fooled by this generator? If I keep questioning it, do you want to give me other sources and everything, and it keeps giving me gobbledygook, do I have the skills to recognize that? Even with What I put into the search when I'm asking it for assistance with something. Am I able to frame the question appropriately, or do I not even have the skills for that? So you have to build up your confidence in this area. The third is going to be about verification. Have I independently verified the output? That sounds authoritative enough. And the fourth one is going back to accountability. Am I prepared to take professional responsibility for the work I'm putting forward? If you're just using your licensed Copilot to make your emails sound more structured, which that is definitely something I do, that's one thing. But if you're just going to hand your entire practice over to AI and think that it's going to go well, you're being incredibly naive. And the mistakes that this will cause for you on every level. From a regulatory perspective, from a client management perspective, from court and costs and everything else, you cannot do this. AI is going to assist you, but it cannot assume your professional responsibility. I understand that you've worked on customer experience, digital transformation, organizational change. So those are all very interesting topics that I don't think many lawyers have the chance to work with or be trained on that service design or the client experience. What can the legal profession learn from other industries about making services more accessible, easier to navigate? I love this question. So when I was starting out, I always heard law is a profession, not a business. Did you hear this as well? Absolutely. Absolutely. And some people will say it's a vocation as well, right? That's exactly it. And it was almost like it was repellent to us to think about the business angle of being a lawyer. And so, no, I don't agree with the statement anymore. I'm— it is absolutely true that we are part of a highly principled profession, a highly principled regulated profession, and that we should all be held to a really high standard. But it's also a highly competitive marketplace. Where we all need to think about what can we do to make ourselves stand out from the crowd. And for especially your listeners that are just starting out, they have to think about how they're going to develop their careers so that they will be fulfilling, that they will support their lifestyle, how they can provide service to others. And of course, because I'm a law pro, how they can meet their professional obligations. So looking at my own background and the different careers I worked in, I'm fortunate that I spent a lot of time in customer service centered fields, and customer service is paramount to being a lawyer in your interactions with your clients. And I don't think that lawyers necessarily understand that clients do not separate the quality of the professional advice or product from the experience that they're receiving. You could provide technically excellent advice, but the client is also experiencing that email that wasn't answered, the bill they didn't understand, the life event that they told you about, but you very obviously did not remember in the next meeting that you had with them, the forms that are confusing, and even any kind of industry, things like your website, if it's hard to navigate that or— You're using terminology that they can't understand. These are all really detracting from the client experience and it's telling against you. And so yeah, customer service and having that kind of project management transformation mindset. Amazing. Thank you for sharing those. I think those are always things that we should constantly be mindful of and be studying and looking at. Once those are in place, it just makes such a difference to get into a workplace that everyone knows what the policies are. Everybody feels a lot more secure and safe to do their work, and they know what the policies are regarding YXE. They know how to navigate those. I loved that you started answering the last question talking about how there is a business and that we need to be aware of that, right? And to be able to support our livelihoods and all of that, we need to differentiate ourselves in this market. So I'm curious about your personal view. What do you think that lawyers should be doing for those especially who are trying to figure out what they want to become known for professionally? Do you have a few ideas on that? Yes. So I know a lot of times I talk about, um, I fell into a niche. I became an expert in an area. And once you're an expert in an area, people come to you, you get more business this way. Once you've got a reputation and an area. So for example, even when I was in admiralty, if there are 4 admiralty firms in the city, well, obviously they're gonna get business cuz there are only 4 of them, but they're so well known, everyone's gonna go to them. But what I find more often than not is that people don't fall into expertise. What they do is they develop their own niche and it's important how you do that. I liked being an expert on things. I was also a generalist for a long time, so I think it's great being a Generalist. But for me, yes, I like to be a subject matter expert and it does, it does steer a lot of business towards you. Over the course of my career, I've become increasingly knowledgeable in certain areas. I'm an underwriter and I specialize in lawyers' professional liability. It is somewhat of a niche area for me to be in, but also as my career has progressed, as I've become a more senior executive, I'd say if somebody was looking at the beginning of their career on how to build that right career for you, it's gonna start with curiosity, paying attention to the things that you find yourself reading about, even when you don't have to do it cuz nobody's assigned it to you. Paying attention to the questions that colleagues keep asking you. Maybe they figured out that you've got an aptitude in a certain area and this is something worth exploring a little bit more. And just keep learning, just constantly keep learning. So as you help other people understand something, people will know that you're the expert in this area. People are gonna start coming to you, and then they're gonna see you're an OBA section executive and you write on LinkedIn about this kind of stuff all the time. Can they pick your brain on something? Can you co-counsel with them? Can they send referrals over to you? You're building your own niche at this point just by letting people know this is something you're really interested in and you want to share that knowledge with others. So if you think about it, it's like curiosity is going to lead you to competence. Competence is going to lead you to contribute to the legal community. And that's when you build up your reputation. And don't wait until you know everything before you start to contribute, because you're never going to know everything in the field. I don't know everything about lawyers' professional liability, and I've devoted a heck of a lot of time to studying this. You're never going to be the subject matter expert that knows everything. You're going to become that expert that is continually learning, and you're willing to share what you've learned, and you're willing to stop and ask questions and learn more along the way. That's beautiful. Thank you so much, Victoria. It's been incredible to, to learn from you during this podcast. I really appreciate your insights. And coming towards the end of our conversation today, I wanted to ask you What advice would you give to law students who may eventually want to move beyond traditional practice into governance, legal operations, technology, or any other legal adjacent role? Did you feel like being the best lawyer you could be while being a full-time practicing lawyer was really the step to be done? That curiosity that you've mentioned throughout the podcast today, what are some of your thoughts on that? Yeah, no, it was definitely more about being curious. But it was having that varied and interesting background. And it was learning, I would say also that what helps you move out of law into another field, it's learning a little bit about all the different aspects of whatever business it is that you're going into. You might start out thinking, this is my narrow role that I'm going to have within the organization. And if that's all you ever want to do for your entire career, then I guess that's okay. But if you don't learn about what's going on in the other departments and what motivates the other aspects of their operations, support teams, their boards, you're never going to get the full flavor of all of the opportunities that are with that organization. And definitely you should volunteer for problems, not just positions. Some of the most valuable opportunities I've had in my career haven't arrived perfectly packaged as a promotion. They've arrived as complicated problems that needed somebody to figure them out. And because I stepped in, I saw that gap, suddenly people are relying on me. And so sometimes it's taking something that looks messy. That nobody else particularly wants and owning it. And that could be an incredibly useful way of moving forward and taking that kind of, that stretch assignment. So you're trying something totally outside of your comfort zone and discovering where you might have an aptitude or skill outside of traditional practice of law. And if you can take ambiguity, if you can understand a problem that maybe isn't obvious to other people when they first look at it. And you can figure out how to bring the right people together or come up with a novel solution, then even though you're not even in a position of leadership yet, you are naturally a leader. You are showing leadership tendencies. And for me and countless other people, when we're looking at moving people up into leadership roles, we're looking for these kinds of attributes, people who already became leaders, even though we never gave them a title for it, because they naturally knew when to step in and support other people. And I think I've said this one a couple of times. Don't wait until you feel you're completely ready for an opportunity to go for it. And I know that as lawyers and underwriters, we are, we can be really cautious about things. And so sometimes it can be really uncomfortable to step outside our comfort zone and take on something that we don't think that we're ready for yet. But you do it and you do it and you adapt. And you stumble and you learn about the role or the problem that you took on, and you learn about yourself and your own grit, and you learn that your career doesn't have to be a straight line. And some of the things that I've enjoyed most about my career were things that I never knew about at the start of my career were ever going to be opportunities or possibilities for me. So I guess my closing advice to people would be your law degree, it gives you options. It doesn't impose an obligation on you to be a lawyer or to practice in a particular way. You get to decide how your own career in law is going to be defined. And it doesn't necessarily mean in private practice. It means whatever you decide it's going to be. Amazing. Thank you so much for making the time to come on the show and share a little bit about your career, some incredible pieces of advice. For those of you listening, thank you so much for making the time to come and listen to the podcast today. I hope you took some notes, and if you haven't, feel free to, to go over and listen to it again. So many great pieces for us to have in our, in our life going forward. I really appreciate it Thank you.

AI Summary

Victoria Crewe-Nelson, Vice President at LAWPRO, discusses her unconventional transition from a diverse private practice in Canada and Scotland into executive leadership. Her career evolution from handling real estate, litigation, and admiralty law to overseeing professional liability, underwriting, and corporate governance highlights the value of adaptability. She emphasizes that a law degree serves as a foundation for various professional roles beyond traditional practice, encouraging practitioners to view their careers as dynamic and choice-driven paths rather than linear trajectories. Central to her professional philosophy is the proactive management of risk and the prioritization of client experience. She provides a nuanced perspective on legal errors, noting that mistakes often stem from communication breakdowns and process failures rather than a lack of technical knowledge. By embracing curiosity and volunteering for complex organizational problems, she suggests that lawyers can build meaningful niches that transcend narrow legal categories and lead to long-term professional fulfillment.

Key Takeaways

  • Professional liability often arises from poor communication, unclear instructions, or missed deadlines rather than a lack of technical legal knowledge.
  • Lawyers should embrace a growth mindset by focusing on how to make risks visible to clients, enabling them to make informed decisions.
  • When using AI tools, lawyers must uphold core responsibilities defined by confidentiality, competence, verification, and accountability.
  • The client experience is not separate from legal advice; quality service includes clear billing, proactive updates, and understanding the client's perspective.
  • Career growth is often accelerated by volunteering for 'problems' within an organization rather than waiting for formal promotions.
  • It is important to cultivate 'healthy skepticism' and verify instructions, especially when faced with urgent requests involving financial transactions.
  • A law degree provides options and flexibility; it does not impose a mandatory path toward a traditional, singular type of practice.

Topics Discussed

Legal career transitions
Professional liability and risk management
Client experience and service design
Artificial intelligence in law
Cybersecurity and fraud prevention
Developing professional niches
Leadership and organizational change
International legal studies

Important Moments

Quotes from the Episode

These were generated by AI and may contain minor inaccuracies.

"Some of the most valuable opportunities I've had in my career haven't arrived perfectly packaged as a promotion. They've arrived as complicated problems that needed somebody to figure them out."

Victoria Crewe-Nelson

"It is absolutely true that we are part of a highly principled profession, a highly principled regulated profession, and that we should all be held to a really high standard. But it's also a highly competitive marketplace."

Victoria Crewe-Nelson

"The lawyer is the one who's responsible in the same way that you'd be responsible for a clerk or a junior associate or anyone else who's doing work and you're signing off on it."

Victoria Crewe-Nelson

Share this episode

Elevating the Client Experience, Making Risk Visible, and Embracing Stretch Opportunities with Victoria Crewe-Nelson

studyinglawaroundtheworld.com

Elevating the Client Experience, Making Risk Visible, and Embracing Stretch Opportunities with Victoria Crewe-Nelson

With Victoria Crewe-Nelson. This week on the podcast, I had the privilege of sitting down with Victoria Crewe-Nelson. Victoria is the Vice President

Professional Liability
Legal Practice Management
Artificial Intelligence in Law
Legal Ethics
Career Development

About This Episode

This week on the podcast, I had the privilege of sitting down with Victoria Crewe-Nelson. Victoria is the Vice President of Underwriting and Customer Service, as well as Corporate Secretary, at LAWPRO (speaking on the show strictly in her personal capacity). After studying law in both Canada and Scotland, Victoria articled in admiralty law and built a wide-ranging private practice across corporate and commercial litigation, real estate, and wills and estates. Since transitioning in-house to LAWPRO in 2012, she has gained a rare bird's-eye view of the entire Ontario legal profession, examining systemic claims trends, professional liability, reinsurance, cyber risk, and organizational governance. We got into why even the most conscientious lawyers face malpractice claims, how to use artificial intelligence without surrendering your professional accountability, and why volunteering for messy problems is the fastest way to step into executive leadership. Overcoming "silent uncertainty" and fraud urgency. Most professional liability claims do not stem from failing to know a limitation period; they stem from communication breakdowns, unchecked assumptions, and leaving a meeting without a written consensus. Victoria explains why true competence means having the confidence to pause a client conversation to research the right answer, and why practicing "healthy skepticism" by picking up the phone to verify urgent wire instructions is essential when social-engineering fraudsters try to bully you into fast action. The four pillars of responsible AI. Artificial intelligence has enormous potential to make legal services more productive and accessible, but an AI tool cannot assume your regulatory liability. Victoria breaks down the four rules every lawyer must apply before using generative AI: Confidentiality (knowing where client data goes), Competence (understanding the law well enough to spot AI hallucinations), Verification (independently checking every source), and Accountability (owning everything that goes out under your name). Why you should never digitize a bad process. Law is both a regulated profession and a competitive service business. Clients never separate the technical quality of your legal memo from the experience of unanswered emails, confusing bills, or clunky intake forms. Learn how to strip away unnecessary client friction before automating your workflows. Guest: Victoria Crewe-Nelson, Vice President, Underwriting and Customer Service, and Corporate Secretary at LAWPRO. Note: Victoria Crewe-Nelson appeared on this episode strictly in her personal capacity. Any views, thoughts, or opinions expressed during the conversation belong solely to her, do not represent the views or positions of LAWPRO, and do not constitute legal advice. Where to listen and how to support the show Search Studying Law Around the World on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or YouTube. If you found value in this episode, please take a moment to follow the show and leave a rating. Selected episodes of Studying Law Around the World are eligible for Continuing Professional Development (CPD) credit with the Law Society of Ontario (LSO) and Continuing Legal Education (CLE/CPD) credit with the Law Society of British Columbia (LSBC).For approved episodes, accreditation details, and participation information, please visit: https://studyinglawaroundtheworld.com/

Sign in to save private notes for this episode

Discussion Board

(0)

Sign in to join the discussion

No comments yet. Be the first!

Disclaimer: Guests participate in Studying Law Around the World in their personal capacity and not as representatives or spokespersons of their employer, law firm, organization, clients, or other affiliated entities, unless otherwise stated. The views, opinions, experiences, and statements expressed during the episode are those of the individual guest and do not necessarily represent the views or positions of any organization with which the guest is associated. Nothing stated by a guest should be understood as an official statement, endorsement, or position of their employer or any other affiliated organization.

About the Guest

Victoria Crewe-Nelson

Canada

Bookmarks

to save bookmarks.

Listen Elsewhere

Newsletter

Get new episodes in your inbox

Join 1,000+ legal professionals receiving new episodes, CPD updates, and career insights.

Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your inbox.

newsletter

Join 1,000+ legal professionals worldwide.

New episodes, CPD updates, and legal career insights — delivered to your inbox.